Irish Setter, Edgerton, Men's, 8", Waterproof, Non-Metallic Safety Toe

**** The Irish Setter Edgerton Men’s Waterproof Non-Metallic Safety Toe boots have garnered a mixed reception from customers, reflecting a diverse range of experiences in terms of comfort, durability, and functionality. Many wearers express high satisfaction with the overall quality and comfort of these boots, often praising their longevity. One customer noted that their husband managed to get over 15 years of use out of his first pair, indicating a strong reputation for durability in some models. Conversely, several users voiced concerns regarding specific aspects of the boot’s performance. While comfort was frequently highlighted, issues with the soles and the boots' claimed waterproof capabilities received criticism. Many customers reported that, despite their expectations, the boots did not hold up as waterproof even after minimal wear. Additionally, there were complaints about the craftsmanship, particularly regarding the pull strap breaking early on and the leather puckering around the eyelets. Another point of contention is the design of the eyelets, which some users found uncomfortable due to their serrated edges that caused irritation. This suggests that while the core features of the boot may appeal to many, certain design shortcomings could detract from the overall user experience. Overall, the Irish Setter Edgerton boots are appreciated for their comfort and potential durability for specific users, but they fall short in terms of waterproof performance and some Construction details, leading to a polarized reception. **